A small foreword on this: This is Arc words and don't expect to see these that often. If I stole any thing from Berserk,it'd be the schedule slip. Originally published:October 5th 2012
Arc Words is a series I'm working on
where I examine manga / anime arc by arc and evaluate how it aids the
work as a whole. I factor in many unfactorable elements but the big
three I use are: characters,story,and enjoyment. These make up, to me
at least ,what makes an arc good, bad,or mediocre . Art factors in but
not as much though and will be mentioned in the other parts of this
review .Note that this will contain spoilers not only for the arc I'm
picking at but occasionally the work as a whole. I'll try to mark
spoilers with a big bold Spoiler,so be on the watch.Also feel free to
point out if I mispell/use story terms.
The first arc on my metaphorical plate is The Black Swordsman arc of
Berserk if you couldn't have guessed from the thread title. This arc is
oft overlooked when it comes to animation. The first part is only
animated in the 1997 TV series and the Guardians of Desire chapters has
never been brought to the screen .Which is sad because this is probably
the most important arc in the context of building the narrative second
only to The Golden Age arc(the part where Berserk gets finger quotes:
Good). Here a few major players are brought in and everything we need to
know about the world is established.
I'll start with our characters:first up is Guts,our "Hero". Yes Guts
is fairly flat at this point of the story but the story provides us with
enough info to make him interesting enough to want to see more of. He
comes off as a complete jerk for most of the arc. However we are shown
some moments of compassion beneath this facade. He rescues Puck,he
attempts to keep the priest and his daughter out of danger and his
speech to Theresa at the end of the arc is genuine and an echo of his
own life. It's established that the Snake baron is very strong and
because Guts defeats him we see that Guts is very strong. There are
numerous references to his sword being nothing but a slab of iron and
Apostles fear his title,Black Swordsman. It intrigues the reader to want
to know how this man became this strong and what his problems are.
Which dovetails nicely into the Golden Age arc that essentially answers
those questions. Remember this sentence you could call it this reviews
Arc Words(Make sure to tip your waitress).
Our second protagonist is Puck the elf and we get a good feel for his
character that he's memorable enough to forget we're not going to see
him for the better part of 12 volumes. He's stupidly noble,naive and a
tenuous bastard not unlike his companion Guts. For this part of the
story he serves two purposes: being Guts' morality pet and the reader's
gateway to the story. His role as the straight man allows the concepts
that need explaining to be explained without feeling tacked on. It
allows the reader a view of this world with out pandering. This is
critical because it allows the next couple of arcs to focus on character
development with out having to worry about the reader being confused.
The other characters will be brought up as they relate to the story
but I'll give special mention to Griffith right here and now. He is set
up as the villain and as Puck says" What happened between these two?"
makes the reader want to know as well. This combined with the little
glimpse we get of him, which dovetails nicely into Golden Age arc which
answers those questions(told you that sentence would pop up again).
Moving down to the story and the meat of this arcs importance:World
building. This story effortlessly brings up just about every major
concept the series has. The first two chapters establish three things:
What a Apostle is, what the Brand does and the kind of world Berserk
takes place in.
Our first look at this world is dark, lawless and ugly. How do we
know this asides form liberal uses of dark colors and shading,though
that does help. It's the The Snake Baron,who has no claim to his title
asides from brute strength(which he has plenty off). He's taken over
the town and people live in fear of him. It shows that the central
government is weak and ineffective or as we later see sick and twisted.
That concept will be cemented in the next arc but for now we have the
groundwork. The mayor of the town cow tows to him because he knows that
he has no support from the outside. Him and by extension these towns are
isolated from each other in this cold nasty world. The technology
present and the methods of execution shown later let the reader know we
are in the dung/dark ages .It allows us to safely insert things we know
about this age and make the world even nastier then it already is.
The second thing is showing what an a Apostle is. Guts used the term
to describe the Baron and the subsequent battle shows us the basic
things that describe an Apostle. One,They are very strong,two you need
to go all out when killing them and three they are monster. By having
Guts fight him,it reenforces the notion that Guts is powerful. This is
all woven in to a cohesive narrative that lays a nice outline for these
concepts.
As we transition into the Guardians of Desire chapters and even
during the previous chapters,the Brand is brought into the story by
first showing the Brand bleeding and nasty creatures being drawn to it.
It shows that it is some how a conduit for them. As Guts travels with
the priest and his daughter,the creatures attack at night again as the
Brand bleeds. This brings up the two thing we know about the Brand and
reenforces them. it bleeds when these creatures are near and it that it
gets particularly bad at night. This allows the story to not have to
explain the Brand later on and lets us know,it's bad news.
The Guardians of Desire chapters take the concept of the Apostle
further and serves as a precursor to Griffith's own fall by showing the
reader the kind of person who would become an Apostle. It also puts
some other concepts on the table.
The Count is shown to be a merciless man who hunts Pagans and rules
with an Iron fist. Calling back to The Baron who also rules under a
similar power= authority method.. Though here the church's power is
shown as the simple accusation of being a Pagan is enough for death. It
validates the ideas that the reader could probably gain about the
setting and further cements the Dung Ages time period with the presence
of the Church Which sets the mood for when the Knights of the Holy
Chain show up in Conviction.
This is also the point in the story that does show Guts' cunning and
endurance through his fighting style of the sword and his hidden arm
cannon. He keeps the latter a secret to pull a fast one on the enemy and
deal major damage. The other quality it brings to the table is Guts'
role as a struggler. A theme that is brought up again and again in the
story. His fighting style banks on insane maneuvers that have a high
potential for failure that reenforces this struggling mentality he has.
Every fight is a fight for his life and it shows that he loves that
kind of thing.
***SPOILERS***
Near the end of this is where the whole creation of an apostle is
done. It first shows that a Behelit is needed. Th concept of the Behleit
is introduced nicely by Puck being understandably ignorant . Doing this
means we don't have to worry about explaining it later in the Golden
Age Arc . So like the Brand we only have to see it to know it's bad
news. Secondly a Sacrifice has to be made and it can't be just anyone
but someone you love. Humanity has to be lost to become an Apostle. This
is where the Count becomes a tragic figure and redeems himself to me.
It shows that he was betrayed by the woman he loved with the very pagans
he hated. In his rage and sorrow he sacrifices her to the God hand,thus
becoming the monstrosity he is. It's fairly heartbreaking and even more
so when he refuses to sacrifice Theresa. This is where the Count makes
it right so to speak by owning up to his sins and going to hell.It shows
that even those who are righteous are still human and can fall. Again a
nice parallel for Griffith's fall later This section also brings up the
God hand and Griffith's entrance into the story to provide the above
mentioned story hook and to make things easier to identify near the end
of the next arc. This whole end also serves to further reiterate that
the Brand and these creatures are connected.
***SPOILERS***
The final part of this story is Theresa threatening to kill Guts and
Guts crying as he seems to be reminded of his past and reflection on
what he's been doing before leaving and going into the Golden Age Arc.
The final part of this review/dissection is enjoyment. This being a
purely subjective thing,feel free to disagree all you want. This section
is really enjoyable because it weaves every aforementioned concept into
a cohesive narrative with interesting/tragic characters The doctor from the Guardians of Desire part, is a great mirror
for what Guts sees himself as and adds even more to Guts as a character.
The two big fights with The Baron and The Count are visceral gore fests
that Berserk would come to be famous for. Even the minor fights are
well done.It's just fun to look and read about. Guts comes across as
likable without being snarky and is a joy to watch fight.
To wrap it up,while I'll admit most of these concepts are fully
realized till later but this Arc plants them into the story
flawlessly.when I hit up the Golden Age Arc I'll go into more detail
about some other material from this part.So yeah,if you aren't reading
Berserk yet ,go change that now. The volumes are easy to find so go out
and buy them like now .
ARC RATING: 4 out 5
Next Time: The Golden Age Arc Part 1
Hi Ulty here, you may remember me from such classic reviews such as Therme Romae and Baki the Grappler, among other. Well I'm back to review thing people may or may not care about and on the stand today is Berserk: Egg of the High King. Sadly though if this movie was on trial it'd be found guilty on a charge of being awful and a few counts of amateur animation.
First a little background,this is the first of a trilogy of movies meant to tell the story of Berserk's Golden Age arc with hopeful attempts to move on to the arcs after that. It covers our main character,Guts, as he meets with the band of Hawks and ends shortly before the battle of Doldrey (I.e the main focus of the second movie). This is where the movie hits it's first major problem.
See what I just described is not the true beginning of the story, it really starts with Guts kicking some ass/world building then starting the big flashback that is the Golden Age arc. So the movie either skips it(in the case of pre flashback events) or hastily explains it( as in Guts' childhood). This trend carries over into the rest of the movie as well. Many minor events that build up the characters and what not are skipped just to rush to the next battle scene. The movie has no sense of pace and feels rushed. It doesn't help that they only had an hour and ten minutes to cover a massive amount of material.
This ties into the next problem,the characters are bad. Without all of the nice character moments to build things up everything just short of happens. Relationships change with little warning and it's jarring . We have no real understanding of the characters and therefore can't get behind them. With no reason to give a shit about them, we can't really care about the narrative either. So in this two legged race both story and character fall flat on their faces at first hurdle.
Okay so maybe the story/characters lost their event to make this a good movie,maybe the animation can win it's event and help at least take home the silver. Well unfortunately, someone put laxatives in it's sports drink and it is just soiling it self all over the course(and with that I've done to metaphors what Guts does to people). What I'm trying to get at is that the CGI is awful. It's like some one was trying to make a PS2 game and then they decided to say screw it and made a movie. There is some better looking animated scenes that only serve to make the others look even worse. To somehow make it even stupider, the changes between the two are clunky enough to give you whiplash. One moment Casca looks fine then the next she's a monstrosity.
Now this is where I saw some nice things about the movie:umm,hold on. Oh yeah, it's mostly uncensored,which is nice because the source material is extremely violent(for a reason). Also Griffith's eyes are still terrifying. Yeah that's about it.
So if you just skipped to here for a simple yes or no, then shame on you go read it then come back down here. My recommendation is skip this garbage and go read the manga or watch the TV series,rage at the ending, then read the manga and enjoy one of the best stories ever written. Until next time,don't die.
As always comments, criticisms and death threats are always welcome.