Of all the Legend of Zelda games I've played, The Minish Cap is definitely one of them. It's hardly a bad game; just a forgettable one. What makes this weird is that the final fight with Vaati left such an
impression on me I shoehorned him into a D&D campaign as a boss. The rest of the game is this big
nebulous blob that; if I revisited it I'd love it but forget about it soon after. This overall feeling of
apathy also extends to the manga adaption.
The story follows the game's plot in a condensed format. Seeing as having chapters of Link wandering around a dungeon with no clue how to proceed would be rather boring and waste what little page count we have, instead each dungeon is treated as an action scene; barring the third temple, which goes into story about a fairy who sings for days then dies. It’s beautifully drawn, like most of the book's art, and serves as a nice transition into a decidedly more serious second half. The Picori are quite a bit more involved in the action here which I feel ties better into their love of humanity. Link is the first human they've been able to communicate with in a long time so of course they'd really love helping and being involved with him. This does however become the root of some of the nitpicks.
Near the middle of the story Link is given a magical feather by the Picori elder, Libari, and at first it's a nice little way to keep Link on the right path without feeling like he's being railroaded. Near the end this feather might as well kill Vaati by itself for all the goofy crap it pulls from making a perfect map of an area to becoming a Roc's cape. Mind you this things back story is that Libari won it off a regular Cucco by kicking its can. The other issue that bugs me is Link's little character arc is poorly defined. Near the end he berates Vaati for using the power of others to strengthening his own and Link relies on his own power. There is just one problem with that: Link is using things given to him by the Picori. There is nothing wrong with getting help from friends but give credit where credit is due and don't act like you did it all. I would chalk it up to poor translation if the rest of the manga wasn't translated well but it isn't so I won't.
I do know that some Zelda fans to take these games more serious than I do and tend to prefer a more
mature experience from the franchise; the fact that this is a more light hearted action comedy might not sit well with some. However I've always seen the franchise as one not afraid to laugh at itself and I can live with the more humorous moments of the book. The character are the right mix of funny and serious so that they still feel like Legend of Zelda characters. Also I do love that Kinstones are
implemented in such a clunky manner that it borders on comedy though it's a nice call back to the
game's actual plot use of them so I can forgive it.
The manga adaptation of The Minish Cap is a fun little romp that ultimately doesn't leave a great deal of impact just like what it's based on. The action is fun and it has possibly the cutest version of the Gleerok I've ever seen. It's worth a read once for the genuinely funny comedy but nothing really worth writing home about.
Till Next Time: Stay Positive
Showing posts with label manga. Show all posts
Showing posts with label manga. Show all posts
Monday, October 26, 2015
Friday, October 9, 2015
Shojo a Go-Go: Komomo Confiserie
Father knows best is a rather antiqued
trope that was rather prevalent in the 1950's but has mostly been
dropped being played straight for the utterly sexist undertones.
Basically akin to always being right and being able to sort out the
silly problems of the doting housewife and children. A variation of
this trope with likes to pop it's head into shojo/joesi manga and is
usually played straight with the boyfriend of the main girl just
knowing better and being a jerk about it. Blue Spring Ride and Happy
Hustle High are good examples of the trope in effect. Komomo
Confiserie seems to have this going on in this story of role
reversal.
Komomo Confiserie tells the tale of a
young girl,Komomo, who in her youth was wealthy and often picked on
the young baker,Natsu, in employ of her father. Now it's ten years
later and she's poor,he's successful and she is at his mercy. The
volume is mostly for setting up who's who and the character dynamics.
It seems to be mostly focused on helping Komomo grow as a person
under Natsu's sadistic thumb. This is where we run into some of the
more disturbing implications of the volume.
Natsu's desire to tease Komomo is
creepy and he's is never truly treated as wrong for his acts. He
hates the idea of anyone teasing her besides him and takes on your
typical threatening poses if someone does. It's clear he's doing the
teasing to help her adjust to life as a average person and the book
will probably justify it as the only way she would learn. However his
friend Yuri joins the cast and is able to teach her a lesson through
kindness and it sticks. So it seems to be less the only way to get
through to her and Natsu likes to just mess with a girl because he
can't admit his feelings. No matter the interpretation it's just not
that interesting to me,this may be due in part to the last chapter
leaving a bad taste in my mouth.
The final chapter of the volume
introduces the coveted school setting and with it come your stock
shojo bullies. Apparently after Yuri taught Komomo about real
friendship she became a saint because nothing seems to phase her
during the bullying. She just writes it off in a way that is rather
mature for a character who really shouldn't be that mature just yet.
She's had some development over the volume but no where near enough
to justify this attitude,so she becomes some what of a purity-sue.
Sure she questions herself later with Natsu about her treatment of
him in their youth but it's assuring her that she meant well in the
end.
In all honesty,this isn't a bad opening
volume. Everything is set-up well enough till the last chapter.Even if the last chapter was handled better it's still nothing really special. Natsu's
attitude towards Komomo has this nasty undertone that is going to be
given an excuse about how it was all for her betterment. Combined with Komomo's baffling new found maturity leaves me with no
desire to read.
Wednesday, August 26, 2015
Shojo A Go-Go: The Demon Prince of Momochi House
First Impressions are somewhat
important,especially with books if you want anyone
to give your book the time of day. The first impression I had with
The Demon Prince of Momochi House was Kamisama Kiss rip off. I
know you aren't supposed to judge a book by it's cover, literally or
metaphorically, but I mean look at the image to your left. It's
clearly Tomoe,same smug look and fox ears but a kimono lifted from
Miketsukami. However once I started reading I was wrong to judge it as such. I mean I was not really blown
away by anything however it did prove the cover was a liar.
The Demon Prince of Momochi House is unsurprisingly a supernatural romance. It's ground well trodden in this column and
this one looks to be no different. I'll give it this it is trying to
be different from books like Demon Love Spell, and Black Bird with a
jerk with a heart of gold male lead. The titular demon prince is
Aoi,a human who transforms into the Nue. The guy is bordering on male
moe and his kindness knows no bounds. His love interest and our lead
is Himari,the 16 year old rightful owner of Momochi House,whose
attempt to claim the house kick starts the plot. She's a generic
shojo protagonist,i.e thick headed with a sweet side and a weak
constitution. She's saved from being the weakest character by Aoi's
demon companions who may as well not really be here for all they do.
Shoujou is the hot headed one and Amazuchi is the guy destined to be
an uke for the inevitable yoai doujins.
The only person I really care about at
this point is Aoi and that's just because he seems to have the most
going on. How he got here and his status as the Nue are the only
things I want to know about about. It helps that he is fairly likable
and his child like antics are amusing. The rest of the cast could
probably be interesting if they had any character but while we get
little for Himari and her loneliness issues the remaining cast is
left lacking.
We have three chapters that serve to paint us
a picture of the world and it does this competently . There is a house on the border of our world and the spirit world that's protected by a supernatural being and shenanigans between the two realms ensue. It's enjoyable fun that serves to showoff Aoi's
powers and a bit of back story on Himori's connection to the house.
Nothing wrong with it and it adds an air of mystery with the
question of who sent the will that brought Himori to the house and
that person's intentions. An interesting twist that is brought up
near the end is that Aoi can't leave the house.
This has the possibility to open up two
paths. Either this becomes the major focus for now pushing the
mystery of will to the back ground or it's an easily solved problem
and this opens us up to a school setting like every other
supernatural romance. The latter can open us up to probably more
bland characters and the school tropes related to that. However the
former has the potential to a hopefully more intimate manga that
allows the characters to grow as they search for answers.Not that they wouldn't grow regardless
of the path but it'd be more of a focus as we're limited to that small cast and the house itself.
There is a interesting undercurrent
lurking here that indicate this manga may go places. Aoi's genuine sweetness
is nice in a genre clogged with misunderstood jerks even if the
everyone else is just sort of there. The plot is not offering much
right now but what is here is written well enough that I'd probably
continue for at least a few more volumes to see where it goes.
Till Next time: Stay Positive.
Thursday, August 20, 2015
Things No One Cares About:After I WIn
Editor's Note:I am unable to figure out the font/spacing issues at this time
It
is left for the readers to decide if it is intentional, but every
time yaoi comes up on this blog it's always Lily “I can't keep a
plot going longer than four chapters” Hoshino's work. In the spirit
of breaking that habit we're going to look at a yaoi manga that is:
A. not by Ms. Hoshino and B. not a collection of sexy short stories.
Instead we're looking at a single volume yaoi manga known as After
I Win. Even though it is given time
to garner some depth it's still kiddy pool shallow.
Now I'm not going to spend an entire article complaining about a book clearly meant to be used as fuel for itching the ditch lacks depth. That would be like playing a Persona game and getting mad because it makes heavy use of Japanese culture.However I am going to complain because it is boring. Every chapter is our lead Hiyori wondering if his dorm mate/boyfriend Kasumi actually loves him. It starts with them unable to communicate and ends with the boys “grabbing burritos” except in the last chapter where they finally “stuff the burritos”. It's like the manga-ka,Kaname Itsuki, decided to condense the plot to Happy Marriage!? and made Chiro a boy. I'll admit I'm a fan of the seme being the younger guy and the uke being older; I would exactly call it a shake-up per se but it adds to the sexy factor...if that's your thing. This still doesn't excuse the fact that the lead couple has the chemistry of wet cardboard.
The only shining moment in this otherwise dark dredge of cute boys is the relationship between Hiyori and his brother Sawa. It's a fine if poorly utilized example of Hiyori being a somewhat unreliable narrator. He see his brother as a playboy seducing scads of high school boys. However Hiyori believes that Sawa doesn't care about people's feelings for which he is wrong. Sawa's care for his brother is a tad subtle, mostly making sure he's eating right, which Hiyori writes off as him being a nutritionist. The book drops little hints that Hiyroi is wrong before just going all out and letting the last two chapters show how much Sawa truly cares.
The book should have been about the brothers with Kasumi being relegated to side status. Sure, he gets some development but his relationships with his little sister and Hiyori are sorely lacking. Has it been about the brothers they could have an exploration of two different lifestyles and the tensions that arise between the men. Instead nothing is really done with the relationship and we are left with bland jock boy hiding his “baton” in the cute sempai. The fact that the brothers are set up as opposites seems to only be there for the twist in the loosest sense, that Hiyroi is the uke. Which is painfully obvious without the unnecessary level of detail to the brother's relationship.
The art is pretty well done with all guys looking reasonably fine however despite the 18+ rating on this no one’s “ink pens” are ever really shown. Also as stated above it's most the two boys just “helping each other read” till the fourth chapter where they “dictate to each other” and if that's your thing then by all means go for it just feels a tad bit lacking to me. Also as a side note the back cover seems to make this book out to be this aggressive fight for love when it's tamer than Pat Boone.
After I Win is a pitiful waste of potential that focuses on the wrong relationship. It's like the manga-ka wrote this detailed back story the brothers and was determined to shoehorn it into this book about sexy guys "drinking milkshakes". The fact that the relationship is competently written weakens the book as a whole since all I can think about is how it should have been about them and not the asinine romantic couple. I know I took a jab at Lily Hoshino earlier but the fact that after 2 years I still remember Night Circus is a testament to some degree of staying power. This is forgettable garbage that lacks any real appeal outside of what could have been.
Till
Next Time: Stay Positive
Wednesday, June 10, 2015
Shojo A Go-Go: So Cute It Hurts!
Gender bender and cross dressing
comedies are something I tend to avoid. Mostly for two reasons, first
they tend to rely on gender stereotypes which are not that funny.
Second is due to deep seated personal issues that prevent me from not
being a sad sack whilst reading them. This is why you'll never see me
talk about Kashimashi despite all five volumes occupying space
on my shelf. So in an attempt to brave the very depths of my
soul,here's So Cute It Hurts!, a cross dressing comedy.
The story follows the twins Megumi and
Mitsuru,who couldn't be more different. I mean them having the same
personality would be rather boring and give a lack of tension down the road. So Mitsuru is a wannabe playboy while his sister
Megumi is a history otaku with an eye patch obsession. She starts out
as the more likable of the two,mostly because she's more relate-able
if a bit weird and also the fact that everything that happens so far
in the plot is a direct result of her brother being an idiot.
The whole cross dressing aspect is for
Mitsuru to get out of taking makeup classes so he can continue his
dating schedule. His character arc is pretty clearly defined for now
as he learns to actually love someone,Shino, instead of just being a
skirt chaser. Shino is deaf ,which has tones of being inspirational
for the sake of it,but hints at hidden depths and okay character
development. Their little relationship is rather cute and solid
pillar of the love “V” the story has set up by volumes end. I
could say this will add tension down the road but I genuinely don't
feel that So Cute! is the kind of manga to defy the norm. It's plot
points are easy to guess and has no real shake ups so I just don't
see anything crazy happening.
Don't get me wrong I actually enjoyed
this first volume,it's rather funny and relies less on gender
stereotypes and more on accidental competence for it's comedy. How
the twins act in each others situation reflects heavily on them as
character. Misturu's school is a crazy place that makes Hekikuu High
look normal so when he goes to Megumi's much tamer school he can
easily outwit the girls with their smaller time pranks and tricks.
Where as Megumi is used to staying out of the way and being in a
school that has a semblance of normal order is thrust into crazy land
and reacts by legging it to avoid problem.
Despite getting the lion's share of
character development,Mitsuru comes off as the weakest character. His
character arc is so clearly defined that it's almost painful and his
semi-ace status is rather annoying compared to Megumi's fish out of
water character. Megumi also has a very well defined “learning to
love “arc being set-up but it's slightly more subtle and her Kitano
like antics are funnier than Mitsuru's verbal humiliation of nasty
girls. The reminder of the cast is pretty okay with hints of actual
character development especially those in the six point love “V”.
I'd like to lodge a few annoyances her that may be fixed in a later volume. First is the fact that Megumi's friends really don't notice they've switched. Which is weird as the appear to be rather close to her and would probably notice something is off. Mitsuru's classmates are a bit forgivable since he tends to stick with girls and is supposed to be the 7th strongest in the school so he may not have many close male friends. Also I know it's common at least in manga and anime for kids to be living on their own but I'd at least like some mention of what there parents are doing,just for context.Again these may come up later and possibly played for drama so for now it just bugs me.
So after that brief soul search,it's
about as deep as a kiddy pool, I've learned absolutely nothing other
than the fact that I enjoyed this volume. The character development
for the leads is rather blatant but has the opportunity to surprise
with the decent supporting cast. The crazy love drama may eventually
overtake the story but for now it's decent comedic sensibilities and
great leading lady make for a fun beginning but I don't put much
faith in keeping this momentum going.
Till Next Time: Stay Positive
Thursday, June 4, 2015
Things No One Cares About: The Legend of Chun Hyang
Recently there has been somewhat of an
influx of manga adaptations of so called classics such as the works
of Jane Austin and Victor Hugo. It's really nothing new, adapting a
classic for modern times is a fairly popular practice.I don't
really look into these “Manga Classics” too much,as I prefer the
source material. These type of titles could be okay for all I know
but I feel that the transition will lack the subtle touches of the
original works. That may just be the snobbery talking in all
honesty,so I'll put that aside to see if CLAMP can make a transition
to manga can work.
Chunhyangga is a Korean folktale that
concerns a young girl betrothed to a noble holding out for his return
even in the face of immanent death. It's a short tale and is supposed
to trumpet the virtues of chastity and rebellion against corrupt
government. I'm not going to give a full review of that because: A.
That's not the focus of this post and B. People care as little about
my subjects as is,so I'm not about to start reviewing books that
people probably care even less about. The Legend of Chun Hyang plays
rather fast and loose with the source material. However faithfulness
to the source is not really the problem here,it's more lack of depth
and inconsistent tone that plague it.
The first two chapters follow Chun as
she combats evil magistrates with the help of Mong Ryong. While in
the original tale,she defies the magistrate through refusal of
advances. Here she is a competent action girl that acts as a
protector of the townspeople. She only thinks of protecting people
and like her folklore counterpart stays “pure”. Women keeping
their “honor” is a minor theme through out the first chapter,
Chun Hyuang's mother kills herself to keep the magistrate from raping
her. Women staying chaste is a common theme in folklore and I won't
really go into the underlying sexist tones this brings to the part.
Mostly because CLAMP was not really trying to make a statement one
way or the other just incorporating elements of the original story of
which there are plenty. Does this excuse it in anyway,no. It just comes off as an oddity in a story that is all about women being on even footing with the men.
The second chapter drops these
connections entirely in favor of becoming a traveling adventure story
with a bit of a Slayers flavor. It's a fun little story filled with
mythical beasts,magical battles,some lite tragedy and confusing
character development. While the first story was a semi retelling of
the original tale,this feels like CLAMP was trying to pitch the book
as a series that never happened. Mong Ryong and Chun Hyang have a typical love/hate
relationship that has Mong Ryong being a lecherous pervert and her
keeping him in line. Near the end of this chapter Chun Hyang nearly
kills a second magistrate but stops suddenly because she realizes it
won't bring back the dead. This comes completely out of nowhere as
she does that exact thing to the last magistrate with no
chastisement.Suddenly revenge is a bad thing...for some reason. If
this series had more time to develop then maybe this could have been
fleshed out but as a stand alone Aesop it conflicts heavily with
what's presented. Chun Hyang,nor anyone really, is not given enough
depth for events to mean anything and the next chapter gives them
depth that they never use.
I'm pretty sure the final chapters
working title was called: “Tone,what's that?”. The chapter
follows young Chun Hyang as she defends the town from young
magistrate's son from the first chapter. The whole thing is treated
as a wacky comedy with implications the the magistrate's son loves
Chun Hyang bur can't show it. First considering the horrific events
of the first chapter this comes of less as charming and more
chilling. Second of all why are we giving semi character development
to character that are already dead. Plus Chun Hyang character
development here apparently didn't take as shes just as impulsive as
a teenager and a child. Though this may be because the original
chapter was not written with this in mind for which it gets a free
pass but this chapter has no excuse. It adds nothing to the first
chapter in terms of motivations and while the first two chapters are
not that serious this chapter is just too wacky.
As a straight adaption The Legend of Chun Hyang fails,as an action adventure story it's pretty average. The short
length and bizarre final chapter, leaves us with a mediocre book that
screams for more. It's a book that clearly wanted to be something
more than it what was presented and that makes me sad to see
something that may have been struck down in it's prime. It really
hasn't colored my opinion on manga adaptions that strongly but I do
recommend it for those looking for a fun action tale.
Till Next Time:Stay Positive.
P.S Sorry for the lateness of this one,again I'm a ditz with schedules.
Wednesday, May 27, 2015
Shojo A Go-Go: Wild Ones
I'll admit I have a soft spot for
gangsters/punks in anime and manga,especially in comedies. One of my
favorite anime is Baccano! due in no small part to most of your
characters being crazy mobsters. Maybe it's he mash up of big tough
guys doing goofy things or manliness to the point of parody. Either
way goofy Yakuza guys are pretty fun and feature prominently in
today's work Wild Ones. Though it does deliver on the funny Yakuza
front it is DOA on every other count.
The volume's main problem is in its'
failure to convey it self properly. We're told everything yet the
story does not reflect the facts given. For example,we're told that
our lead,Sachie,was chosen by the men of her grandfather's gang but
at no time does this seem to be the case. Yes she does show some very
admirable traits but this is long after she's gained these men's
admiration and most of them only happen in front of her love
interest(?), Rakuto. Over all it comes off as a lazy, instead of
having events shown that back up your statement,just tell us the
statement I mean it's not like we're in a visual medium or anything.
That aside the story doesn't seem to be
going anywhere really and seems to be okay with standard plots albeit
with a yakuza flavor. Sachie has to deal with moving to a new school
and the loss of her mother among some wacky guys who just don't
understand women. It's by no means bad and if you're like me and are
okay wacky yakuza shenanigans then you'll be fine. It just lacks
substance and doesn't seem to be wanting to go much further in terms
of plotting or character development
Sachie and Rakuto are the only two
characters of any real note her as the rest are either goofy
gangsters or shojo stock jerks. If you noticed my confusion about
Rakuto being a love interest,it's because the volume doesn't know
what Sachie thinks about him either. Sachie constantly calls him
weird but he's not that weird. He has a little more formal speech and
aside form one instance of personal space invasion is not that
bizarre. He's not that interesting so I can see why she falls in and
out of love so easily with him;He's the generic cool guy that
attracts crazy girls and can do it all.
Sachie on the other hand is the
spitfire girl that tougher than she is letting on. When she does go
into full on scolding mode it leads to some of the funnier sections
as the guys stand bewildered at her. Again it's not exactly ground
breaking comedy but it's still enjoyable and works for the most part.
Her history with her mother is probably the only thing that has
potential to be interesting or it could just turn out to be Tohru
Honda's back story but with Yakuza.
I actually enjoyed the Wild Ones quite a
bit despite it's laziness and weak story. Does that mean you'll like
it,probably not. Unless you're a fan of gangsters and comedy then
you'll probably be left wanting,hell I like both of those things and
I'm left with that cold emptiness. Though I always feel that so it
may not be the book's fault. It offers little incentive to continue
and is only worth it if you're desperate for a romance story.
Till Next Time:Stay Positive
Wednesday, May 20, 2015
Things No One Cares About:Tomodachi No Hanashi
Tomodachi No Hanashi or The Secret of
Friendship revolves around two girls: The beautiful yet caustic Moe
and the plain push over Eiko. Moe easily attracts the boys but most
are turned off by her condition for being with her, Eiko must be put
first by them. While the book never attempts to portray it as
anything but unreasonable it does take the time to flesh out why Moe
thinks this is a reasonable request. The story is split into 3
sections each from a different characters perceptive and how they
deal with Moe or in the last sections case how Moe sees everything.
It still forms a cohesive story that contemplates what friendship
means to different people and how it affects them.
The first section follows Eiko as she
deals with Moe's relationship with Tsuchida, a guy smitten enough to
go along with Moe's requirement. Eiko is really embarrassed by the
fact that she's being dragged along but she is way to nice to
actually say no. Instead she starts lying to Moe,which is a stride
forward in her development to being a stronger person. She's growing
because of her friendship's with the other two as the other two learn
that they can be themselves around her. Eiko's development after this
is rather down played as the story shifts focus to the other
characters but it's done rather well regardless. This part ends on
Moe dumping Tsuchida for her perceived callousness towards Eiko. The
events here do make both girls come of as a bit selfish is some
regards but it serves to highlight how deep this relationship really
is. This is more deeply explored in chapter three once we get Moe's
side of things.
The second part follows Tsuchida's
friend Narugami as he deals with the fallout from the previous
chapter. His role for most of the part is that of vengeful jerk,the
part usually filled by random bitchy girls. However the major
difference is that the book explains his feelings, Moe hurt his best
friend so he's going to go after her best friend. He has his own
hang-ups with women and his arc concerns learning that women are
people too and that the way he treated Eiko was wrong.
The advantage of his perspective is
that we see an outsider's take on Eiko and Moe's friendship. To him
it seems terribly lop sided but as he starts to talk to Eiko he sees
how similar it is to his friendship with Tsuchida. It fits in with the
books theme of friends are forever and to hell with what others think
of them. Through out the book the characters are shown as awkward
around others but it doesn't matter to them since they have each
other. While it does get a little heavy handed it never veers into
preachy instead just showing how these friendships affect the
characters.
The final part is told from Moe's POV
as Narugami attempts to make up with the girls and dealing with his
love for Eiko. It is some what side lined as a huge part of it is
Moe's perspective on why she is friends with Eiko and why they are so
close. With all this back-story laid out it paints the previous parts
in a new light. Moe's reasons for her crazy actions are much more
clear now: Eiko gets her like nobody else does and she only wants
Eiko to be happy because then she'll be happy
It's here where the more yuri inclined
fans can read Moe's actions towards Eiko as slightly lesbian in
nature. I don't particularly feel that way as its more about Moe
reacting to her best friend changing than actual romantic jealously
towards Narugami. The romance is playing out and again we are on the
outside looking in as Moe struggles with abandonment issues and her
friend changing. It gives Moe much more depth as a character and
adds an interesting side we don't see that often.
The only real weak point to me is that
Tsuchida falls off the face of the earth for most of the final part.
Which given how deep his and Narugami's relationship is supposed
feels weird. Especially when Narugami is trying to date his ex's best
friend. Given that friendship is the major theme and Moe and Eiko's
has such much nuance and depth; it's odd that Narugami and Tsuchida's
relationship is hardly explored past chapter two. Again more of a
nitpick since Narugami's character development is solid on it's own.
There is a side story in the book about
a girl trying to catch her friend's boyfriend cheating on her. Along
the way she meets the guys friend and it blossoms into to romance.
Very sweet navel gazing chapter that ponders how far are people
willing to go for friends. A nice compliment to the main story but
nothing special over all
Tomodachi No Hanashi is an interesting
little book that digs in to the exploration of friendship without
being cheesy. The three different perspectives really help make the
relationships work and give the story some more interesting facets .
Featuring way more character development than I would expect for a
manga of this length and a very tight if minuscule cast. It's a
sentimental journey that you shouldn't miss out on.
Wednesday, May 6, 2015
Things No One Cares About: Happy Hustle High
Rie Takada has gained a bit of good will back with me via Gaba Kawa. It was well written,had decent characterization and an okay ending. Was it amazing,not particularly, but compared to Takada's other popular works it is brilliant. That may be a bit too harsh to Happy Hustle High,it's insulting but over all just sort of generic.
The story is your
typical girl meets boy,boy ignores girl, and then guy and girl fall
in love. The basic plot concerns an all girls school going co-ed and
how that affects the students. It works for the most part but the
plot point never comes up that much after our lead, Hanabi gains
rank in the student council. Instead focusing on Hanabi and Yasukai
relationship,which is okay, it is a romance story after all. Up till
around the mid way point everything is going along fine then Hanabi
and Yasuaki finally get together and it all goes down the tubes.
The second half has
no idea where it wants to go and like me trying to fill space,and I
realize I didn't care about the characters at all. They aren't bad
characters per se just boring stock shojo characters. As a result of
this revelation,I can't be asked to get invested in the story and I'm
left questioning why I even cared in the first place. The problems
are a result of the characters being stupid and not in the too broken
to fix things way. It's more like The World God Only Knows making up
problems that shouldn't be an issue but suddenly are.The story is
trying to have an underlying theme and this is where the book goes
from meandering idiocy to full blown flaming train wreak of
insulting.
Love can change is
a common theme in shojo and Rie Takada is rather fond of it in her
works. Unfortunately, her use of it is rather insulting and is the
biggest problem I have with this book. Hanabi starts out as the brash
protector of all her friends and her entire character arc is moving
away from this image and style. Becoming less impulsive is fine but
however quite a few of the boys have this same problem or similar
problems and it's never treated as bad. So it comes off as Hanabi is
too boyish and needs to become more girly to be a happier person.
Hanabi's problems that are less problems and more she's not a girly girl, how dare she. The book has no respect for girls in general, the only girl with any not is Hanabi and her personality is too boyish to be respected by the book. They are all a nameless mass that can't resist the sexy boys that they are now cohabiting and therefore are useless. The boys are just as interested in the girls of the school but are treated as cool people who can look above base urges. The one time the girls stand up for themselves in what is the Shojo equivalent of Rape Squad they are all berated for being silly and that the guys should handle the girl's problems. The way Yasuaki is portrayed does not help the book's case.
Yasuaki arc
concerns his fear of women but it's never given much time outside of
a few chapters and I genuinely forgot it was a problem till it's
magically solved by having sex with Hanabi. Other than that anything he
does is treated as right and Hanabi is being silly for not trusting
him. Had he actually expressed his thoughts then they could avoid
most of these issues. This could actually be a problem that needs
addressed but it's never treated as such and his only change that
happens is him stating he's happier. I'm sorry I didn't realize you
were unhappy,as you enjoyed surfing and that's about it.I mean he could be, he's not that deep or nuanced.
Sadly these
problems are not exclusive to Happy Hustle High but it is a more
blatant example of how this can easily fail. It's
insulting in what the author thinks of her own gender and her
idolization of men. Had they balanced out both sides and making them
equally flawed and I could forgive it but it doesn't. It's by no menas a bad series,and got a laugh form me on occasion, but it doesn't excuse the utter banality of the whole mess or the dim view on the female gender.
Till Next Time: Stay Positive
Thursday, April 9, 2015
Things No One Cares About: Mr.Flower Bride
I spent an entire month talking about
Arina Tanemura so let's move on to someone different,Lily Hoshino.
She's been featured here a couple of times before for her yaoi
collections and after last months heterosexual extravaganza, I could
use a shake up. Mr. Flower Bride is yet again a collection of yaoi
stories though the volume neglects to mention the other stories
instead focusing on the titular story. I can forgive it though since
the other stories are far less interesting and take up space that
could have been used for the better main story.
The Mr. Flower Bride chapters focus on
Aoi and Shinji as they get swept up in Shinji's family tradition of
marrying the youngest son off to a guy to prevent succession disputes
among the children. While this could be an interesting jumping off
point for dealing with people forced to love a person of a gender
they have no interest in,this is never explored. It does however take
a short time to show Shinji coming to terms with his attraction to
Aoi despite his worry of getting Aoi involved in a tradition that
people view as a punishment in someway.
The remaining chapters detail their
wedding night and a few other isolated events and it works well to
develop their relationship and how it affects others. I wouldn't call
the characters fully developed but they work well enough for the
short time we see them. Like My Only King there is the starting of
something rather interesting here but it fails to follow through. The
story right after that is a role reversal of the main couple's
archetype and actually lends a little more to building up the setting
with more insight into this tradition. Letting this run alongside the
main story would actually be interesting as a way to expand the
setting. However, my hopes for this story will have to wait for the sequel as it's pushed aside for more one shots.
The other two side stories are just
sort of sitting there. One's about a bodyguard who needs protecting
and a pretty boy in a brothel finding his true love. It's well trod
ground for yaoi and seems to be struggling for a reason to exist
outside of fulling a boy sex quota. The latter story breaks the mold
that the book set by again putting a girly uke in it. Up till now the
manga-ka had stopped drawing her ukes too girly. They were just
feminine enough to work and the role reversal chapter works better
because of the style. However,here he's back to being a borderline
trap,and while not a bad story, it's was done better in The Seabed
of Night. On there own these would be okay stories but here they
are interrupting a better story and lack the interesting aspects and
developments of the main story..
Like Mistress Fortune, the main story
is going along with the sillier bits with a wink and a nod. Unlike
that however it does try to build a setting that works and examine
different facets of this relationship. The more stand alone style of
the chapters could form an interesting tale given the time but this
was a story shot in the legs and left for dead. Overall not worth
it,unless all you want some nicely drawn guy loving.
Tuesday, March 31, 2015
Things No One Cares About: Mistress Fortune
Reaching the end of this horrid month,we arrive at Mistress Fortune. I originally planned this as the follow up to Jojo month but for reasons lost to myself I didn't. Now I'm back with a vengeance to talk about my very first Arina Tanemura book. I have no deep story about why I picked this,it didn't call to me with a ground breaking premise or because a friend fervently recommended it to me. Nope,just picked it up because the pink and white spine looked nice. Well, now that I've outed myself as a vain idiot,let's talk about Mistress Fortune...finally.
Mistress Fortune shares a lot of
similarities with the earlier I.O.N, in that both girls have psychic
powers and are close to boys as a result. There is even a nice little
call back to the flying scene from I.O.N as well as a few other
series including Phantom Thief Jeanne. They both also feature a
romance plot that slowly but surely overtakes the more fantastical
elements. The only difference here is that the psychic plot is meant
to play second fiddle to the main romance. Indeed everything is a
side note to the romance between Kisaki and Giniro and every
characters is semi aware of it.
The plot is a rather loose magical girl
set-up that serves to help the main couple grow. The monsters or EBE
as they are called are less harbingers of destruction and more
oblivious tourists. Heck the first one the team fights, becomes a
regular character and gets her own side story about becoming a
socialite. The interpersonal drama between our two leads is mostly
played for laughs,he's more interested in her tracts of land and this
makes her angry. However when they do buckle down and get serious for
a bit,there is some surprising tenderness in the relationship despite
it seeming to be an aesthetic attraction. Once the apparently
inevitable rejection scene comes up,it actually works this time.
Mostly because again the romance is the focus so it's fairly
important and she is actually rejecting him for a solid reason
instead of just plot extender.
The characters themselves are not
bad,more generic than anything else. Kisaki is one missing parent
short of your typical shojo heroine and Ginro is the hot guy with the
troubled past. Their director,Dr. Gunjo is a goofy jokester and
Ebe-ko,the monster,is your wacky non-human sidekick. This can be
forgiven as the cast is rather funny and likable. Ginro's love for
the Kisaki's lady lumps and his inability to keep his mouth shut
about them at risk of injury is funny. They all play their role well
and get a few good jokes off.
This is shojo fluff through and
through, attractive characters having a relationship that will be
forgotten soon enough. I feel that Arina Tanemura is acknowledging
her worse habits here and working with them as opposed to letting
them run wild. It's just self aware enough that I can forgive the
weaker elements while not being over reliant on them to the point of
taking me out of the story.
So as I lay here at the bottom of the
ravine dying slowly,alone and in pain, at least this month ended on a
high note. I started this month for no real reason other than to have
an excuse to read through some works of a prolific manga-ka. It's had
it's ups and downs and while I won't claim I really know Tanemura's
works better, I have a better feel for her when I get to her longer
works. So I'll see you next time where I'll probably be a ghost or
not mention that I died ever again
Till Next Time:Stay Positive
Wednesday, March 25, 2015
Things No One Cares About: Time Stranger Kyoko
Since I'm feeling pretty good after Phantom Thief Jeanne,the inevitable crash should be coming pretty soon. What's that over there, is it a great series for me to read? Nope,it's just a poorly paced and boring waste of a cool setting or as it's called in common tongue Time Stranger Kyoko. Was that playing my cards too early,probably, not that I care too much.
Time Stranger Kyoko lays out an
interesting premise then proceeds to never flesh it out and throws in
new elements to it without warning. The Earth has been united as one
nation and we follow the princess of Earth,Kyoko. She is gathering
mystical stones and their respective users a.k.a Strangers to awaken
her sister Ui. That's all we get for how the world seems to work,
which is lacking to say the least. It leaves quite a few more
interesting aspects relegated to sidebars,such as hybrids of humans
and earth's other life forms. Something that should probably be
explained is mentioned once as a definition then never explained
further. How this works or how people like that came to be is instead
pushed aside for wacky thieves and helping a guy over come his daddy
complex.
This brings up the second big problem
with the story:pacing. The first volume moves at a glacial pace with
little to no world building and getting involved in adventures that
just happen to tie back in to the main plot. This continues well into
volume two before finally getting to interesting events,involving
Akira the thief and the snake tribe's political turmoil. After this
stretch of still not explaining much else the plot starts running at
breakneck speed to get all the macguffins needed for the ending to
happen. Throwing in plot points and trying for a bit of foreshadowing
that all gets lost because it never takes anytime to breath.
There are some interesting ideas that
actually do work, once the main group figures out that the stones are
in the hands of the various tribe's rulers they call them all to the
castle instead of cavorting about to find them. Also to be fair the
foreshadowing with Kyoko's true nature is actually done rather well
early on but fails by being a bit ham handed once the plot kicks into
overdrive. The series also plays fast and loose with the time travel
aspects. Which is better in the long run since closely examining the time travel would not turn out well for this book. Since
I'm being nice to the series,I'd be remiss if I neglected to mention
Akira.
Normally when talking about characters
I'd start with the main one,Kyoko in this case, but in the interest
of putting my best foot forward,I'll start with side character
Akira. He's a lovable rouge and unlike the others flits between goofy and serious rather well. The brother of the Snake tribe's leader that commands a band
of thieves in the capital city. Everything about him works: he's
funny,cool,has a tragic yet believable back story and brings energy
to a main cast that has none. The way Kyoko is characterized it seems
to be setting him up as her love interest as opposed to her actual
one. They instead just send him off in the end to do his own
thing,probably for the better because everyone else is kind of boring
and crap by comparison.
Speaking of Kyoko,she's all over the
place in terms of character. It's clear she's supposed to be the fun
determined kind of person but she keeps getting these selfish
moments. The plot is kicked off by her being selfish to avoid be
exposed as Earth's princess. You can have a character like this work
if the balance is right, Josuke Higashikata strikes a solid mix of
kindness and being greedy. It's like Tanemura is afraid to make a
straight forward and honest protagonist so she shoe horns in these
more selfish actions to hide it. When she has to be gone for a few
chapters after she is revealed as the Time God's daughter, which is
also never really explained by the way. The others miss her deeply
but it seems to be because the reawakened Princess Ui is rather
unpleasant.
Sakataki and Hizuki,
step brothers and the body guards of Kyoko probably fare the worst as
along with Kyoko get into one of the worst subplots in the book. They
kick of a few plot points with the stones and establishing a monster race that seems to be here simply so the characters has
something to fight on occasion. Near the end the get into a terrible love triangle that serves little purpose other than to extend
the story and so that weird plot Tanemura set up has some resolution.
They do get some funny bro-con moments but it's intermixed with
serious angst. Sadly, this works about as well as Kyoko's
characterization.
The brothers are both Strangers and
Hizuki happens to be the last Stranger they are searching for and
this plot point is just dropped so unceremoniously that it's
laughably bad. It doesn't help that he is the Ice Stranger when there
is already a Snow Stranger. Yes snow and ice are rather different but
she could have used a different element or made Sakataki the Snow
Stranger in lieu of him being the Crystal Stranger. It'd work better
from a theming stand point at least
The reminder of the cast is
forgettable,especially the remaining Strangers that don't even have
their own chapters. Making their desire to see Kyoko come back to the
world even more bizarre since they've known her for all of about five
pages. Chronos the time god comes out of no where and like most other
probably important points in this story is never expanded upon. He
seems to be here again to add drama and draw out a plot that should
have finished ages ago but didn't because we didn't have a romantic
ending yet. Then we get an epilogue and no offense but half these
characters had maybe a handful of panels. So why in the name of all
the is unholy would I give a crap about what they did after this.
This is a series that doesn't seem to
want to focus on anything,squandering a rather interesting setting
and neglecting to build up the world. Instead focusing on
inconsistent characters that range from unpleasant to just outright
cardboard cut outs whose role could be fulfilled with a ambitious
batch of custard and a plot that is determined to break some sort of
speed record. See you next time at the bottom of the ravine for
Mistress Fortune.
Till Next Time:Stay Positive.
Tuesday, March 10, 2015
Things No One Cares About: I.O.N
It's time for another theme month. These tend to work out great for me,so this will turn out awesome too. This month I'm looking at Arina Tanemura,whose books keep ending up in my collection by complete accident. So might as well clear out a good chunk of them,before more show up,and the best place to start is the beginning with I.O.N.
I.O.N is Tanemura's first published
book and while the story and art are rather strong the romance is
lacking. It wouldn't be too bad if the story wasn't solely about the
romance. The world is fleshed out rather well for the one volume
length and the story is fine till it is derailed by the romance.
Enough with broad strokes and romance potshots, lets go more in depth
with these potshots.
The story follows Ion Tsuburagi, a girl
with minor physic abilities when the story starts. As events progress
her powers increase and she gains the attentions of a boy, Mikado.
with an interest in physic powers. We've somehow stumbled into the
shojo counterpart to Sussano,with less craziness. The central
conflict stems less from we can fly/lift objects and those
ramifications and more from does Mikado view Ion as a girl or a
experiment. I could forgive what seems to be a glorified romance
subplot taking over the plot if the main players had any chemistry.
Ion and Mikado really don't play well
off each other and seem to be in love because the plot demands it.
She claims to love him because he says his mind,no matter how cheesy.
He loves her because I guess they worked together for a while and to
spite his ex. Once he starts returning her affections,it derails the
more interesting physic powers plot,for romance drama. Ion herself is
a bit all over the place in terms of her affections,being aggressive
but chickening out,then going back to being aggressive in time for
Mikado to be stupid.
The other characters fare no better in
they all tend to blend into one big forgettable ball. Both main
characters have a rival for their partners affections. Kouki is the
eternally rejected suitor of Ion and him and his lackey can be funny
but add little to the plot outside of drama with club formation that
goes away quickly. Mikado's ex,Ai, is nicely realistic for a love
rival in that she doesn't try to do anything really crazy to
Ion and when she accidentally hurts her feels genuinely remorseful.
Her presence does bring up something that infuriates me. She has
physic powers as well,weaker ones but still powers. The story brings
up the fact that there is research on physic powers and people
clearly have them but that is never really addressed in terms of how
this could affect the world. I know this is a shojo manga and romance
tends to reign supreme but come on don't leave me hanging on the
better plot or at least don't let it all crash down.
The final chapter train wreaks due to
having to follow the boneheaded rejection that is there to create drama rather than actual add to the story. at the end of chapter five.
The plot sets up that a weird substance is amplifying Ion's powers
but the final chapter throws in the fact that it is breaking apart
and her powers will diminish. I get that it's aiming for a bit of a
symbolic loss of her connection to Mikado but the guy just rejected
her and she's genuinely heartbroken,so why does she care. Mind you I
think the other characters are just as perplexed at her bounce back
but the whole chapter seems to be here because we can't have a sad
ending.
For her first full book that,going by
the author notes, was wrote with very little knowledge of how many
chapters she would have;the world is well fleshed out barring that
final plot point. The romance could have worked if the leads weren't
together solely because of a red noose or the cast wasn't for the
most part shojo stock chracters. Arina Tanemura month is off to a
poor start but I'm not one to stop after a bad start,I'm kind of
stupid that way. So see you next time for the first volume of Phantom
Thief Jeanne.
Tuesday, August 26, 2014
Things No One Cares About:Punch!
Love can make a person act somewhat crazy,do activities they may otherwise despise,or cause them to hatch extremely convoluted plans,such is the case with today's main event Punch!. It's one of those stories that is actually not that bad but has nothing really special about it either. There is some great comedic moments that aren't that memorable which perfectly compliments the forgettable story . There is effort put into to it but it ultimately fails to leave any impact on the reader
The female lead is
Elle,who comes from a family that is involved with boxing and lives
in a gym ran by her grandfather. She rejects her arranged marriage
based less on the guy being terrible and more on the idea she views
him as a brother. A concept neither her grandpa nor her fiance can
understand and write off as her being a brat. Which is not surprising
because she acts very childish,from her speech to bringing home a
street punk archetype who serves as our romantic lead,Kazuki. He's
the more mature of the two even if he takes a shine to her because
she looks like his family dog. His love for fighting boarders on the
fetishistic and he has that jerk with a heart of gold schtick going
too. That is really about it for him personality wise,and it's not
that interesting. By extension this makes the main romance really
uninteresting,as the two leads have no chemistry at all.
Once they start
formally dating it's the “I'm a jerk but I love you” routine that
doesn't work. They even take the time to flesh out his back story
with his blind sister and all these things he's seen and it's still
not interesting because he lacks a personality outside of stoic. Elle
is a childish idiot but still has personality. The struggles she
faces are more relate-able ,i.e trying to forge your own path.
However once she starts dating Rugged Mcbland, her desires to leave
the gym go clean out the window as now she has a sexy fighter
boyfriend to keep her interest as opposed to genuine enjoyment. It's
insulting to say the least and kills any chance that Elle had for
character development.
The rest of the
cast is a collection of idiot meat heads and female shojo archetypes.
Her fiance does have a jerk side that shows more as the plot goes on
that becomes over the top. He gets his own side plot where he decides
to get back at Kazuki by wooing his sister. It's really enjoyable
watching this guy try to be sinister while paying for this girl's eye
surgery and leads to a really funny title drop. There is also this
nice twist to the crazy admirer's trope in that Elle promptly curb
stomps them because she remembers she actually is a great athlete.
The plot itself
acts like a shonen sports manga but focusing on the lead character’s
girlfriend instead. This has potential to be rather funny but it
forgoes that in place of shojo melodrama. The events these characters
get into are not boring and stay with in the realm of plausibility
but because the charters are bland and uninteresting you don't care
what happens to them. The latter half of the plot deals with Kazuki
potentially not being able to box ever again but Kazuki is a poor
character so I couldn't give less of a darn. Then the story has the
guts to time skip to a completely bland match up between the main two
boys in Elle's life that no one was asking for.
There is a rather
well paced and decent plot barring that time skip hiding in these
pages but alas it also has terrible characters hiding with it as
well. As stated above there was genuine effort put into this series
but it's not enough to make up for it's problems.
Till Next Time:
Stay Positive
Tuesday, June 24, 2014
Things No One Cares About: Wanted
I've touched upon the vampire craze that was kicked off by the likes of Twilight while talking about Diabolik Lovers. Since people like to capitalize on a fad to make some easy cash, we received the mediocre Vampire Knight. Then because many teenage girls tend to have poor taste,that tripe took off in America. After that because again people do enjoy money,someone translated Wanted and let it loose upon the masses.
Wanted is a shojo manga that was
written by Matsuri Hino in 2002,collected into a single volume in
2005 and then finally released overseas in 2008. She is better known
for Vampire Knight which was used by Viz to ride on Twilight's
coattails. Then Wanted rode on Vampire Knight's coattails to make a
weird chain of poor writing. Though Wanted does bring up a few issues
that I have with Vampire Knight,I'm going to leave it alone. Mostly
due to the fact that I haven't read the whole series and it could
have improved.
Wanted has some very weird issues with
women in that it seems to hate our protagonist Armeria. We open up
with her being smart and capable enough to infiltrate a band of
pirates but once she does that competence goes out the window. She
becomes a perennial screw up that has to be bailed out by Captain
Skulls. She's also incredibly stupid in that she never seems to
figure out that the man who looks like her lost lover is actually her
lost lover. You think for someone who could trick pirates that she'd
be pretty clever but no every plan she has is incredibility short
sighted. I guess she need to level up her moe so that Skulls will
decided to keep her around.
Skulls on the other hand has to
constantly save her stupid behind and then act like he doesn't want
to. So of course he gets to be competent and tough all the time
befitting his back story of growing up amongst pirates and becoming
their captain. While Armeria despite being an orphan who had to fend
for her self from a young age is treated as weak and useless. It
makes me question why they didn't just have her get captured and
just go from there. I know that love can make you do stupid things
but this is taking that concept too far.
Skull himself is a bit of a Marty Stu
that can seem to pull off anything he wants with little to no effort.
He's set up as this perfect guy who's only flaw is being a pirate but
even then he's a noble pirate. He never seems to do anything nasty
outside of being the kind of cold person I guess I should fall for
because deep down he's really sweet. However his jibes towards
Armeria come off as very demeaning and lack any affection they were
meant to have. So in the end were left with a pretty jerk ,the sort
litters the pages of many a poor Shojo and Josei manga.
A quick side note on style,despite how
much I made fun of R.I.P I don't mind a Gothic sensibility and
admittedly Vampire Knight did benefit from a more macabre art style.
However this story is more nautically styled which makes this
wonderfully drawn tattoo of the Grim Reaper on Skulls' chest seem out
of place It's lovingly crafted on the authors note page,next to an
ignored request to not over analyze this book. Why she felt the need
to put it in this story of all places is a mystery. Yes it is his
identifying mark but this is a pirate setting giving him a bedazzled
eye patch or a scythe earring would make more sense.
The story is nothing really special,it's a shojo romance adventure but with pirates . The first chapter
gets the character introductions out of the way,then we get a chapter
where they confess their feelings because Skulls was being a jerk and
didn't do it last chapter. Then it wraps up with generic pirating
tomfoolery that is exciting as erosion. Mind you not every story has
to be some groundbreaking tale that makes me question my very being
but it helps if it's at least exciting. Hell,it's so uninteresting
that it starts opening up plot holes in an attempt to give me more to
harp on.
The band of Pirates themselves are the
Robin hood style thieves and the first two chapters supports this.
They steal from nobles,sets up a haven for the downtrodden and
genuinely improve life for the less fortunate. Then once chapter
three rolls around they go on a highly dangerous quest that will
help the commoners if it's successful but it's more treated like a
journey of pure self interest. Not once are the people they are so
willing to help brought up. It's such a weird turn in events that
doesn't mesh with what little we know of these characters. I again
question why use this characterization if it is going to be thrown
out the window on a whim.
There is a one shot at the end of the
book that the Hino says inspired this tale of poor quality. Funnily
enough,it's a much better written piece than the story it inspired.
Mind you it's nothing special still,but at least the main girl isn't
as insulting. She genuinely wants to defy her station in life and
become a doctor in a setting that frowns upon those ambitions. Not
for the affection of a man but because she loves knowledge. However
she starts pursuing this man who clearly has no interest in her until
she forces her company on him constantly. Then his hipster senses
start tingling and realizes this girl isn't mainstream and starts
loving her. How this translated into girl who shouldn't be useless
and Marty Stu pirate captain is beyond me.
This is a boring story filled with
characters ranging from generic to downright insulting. I can't tell
if Hino can't write good female characters or she can and chooses not
to keep her damsel complex going. You see the same issue in Vampire
Knight with a female who shouldn't be useless having to be constantly
saved by angsty men who can tell her they love her. It's an idiotic
and demeaning view to put out even if it's for the sake of fulfilling
a fantasy
Till Next Time: Stay Positive
Tuesday, May 6, 2014
Things No One Cares About: Rohan Kishibe Won't Move
Hirohiko Araki is best known for his long running manga Jojo's Bizarre Adventure,of which I dedicated and entire month to. When I first did that little stunt I had only read up to the third major arc,Stardust Crusaders,and had not experienced the unbridled pleasure of Diamond is Unbreakable.This part introduced the character of Rohan Kishibe,an eccentric manga-ka.Araki loves this character and says that if he himself had a Stand it'd be Kishibe's Heaven's Door. He has even given Rohan multiple spin-offs dealing with his escapades,including today's feature:Rohan Kishibe Won't Move.
Rohan Kishibe Won't Move is a
series of short stories involving the titular character as he gets
into odd situations while researching topics for his manga protects.
The first story ran in Shonen jump in 1997 with the rest being
published in a few different magazines between 2008 and 2013. The
stories range from tales of suspense to the horrors of real estate.
They are interesting little stories that let us see more of Rohan as
a character and the weird things that go on in the Jojo universe.
The first two stories,At a
Confessional and Mutsukabezaka,use
Rohan as more of a framing device for the stories. Both are fun
little thrill rides that give me that Twilight
Zone
vibe albeit with a much lighter tone. At a Confessional is probably
the better of the two for its climax that elevates catching popcorn
in your mouth into a fight to stay alive. I won't say much more about
it as not to spoil the hilarious twist ending.
The
second story is by no means bad,being just as weird as its
predecessor but has a scene that really bugs me. Near the middle of
the story,the female lead kills her lower class lover by accident..
The problem is that he keeps on bleeding form a rather small wound.
However she has to hide him as her father and arranged fiance are
coming. She starts hiding his possessions and then for no reason
strips down to her underwear. Then proceeds to stay that way till she
hides the body and this scene goes on for awhile. I think she might
have got blood on her dress but her dress looks the same from the
time she sees her boyfriend till she takes the dress off. The series
has had fan service before but it was never this obvious or drawn
out. Which is a shame because we do get to see a bit of how weird
Rohan can be and the rest of the story is enjoyable if a bit vague.
The
third story,The
Millionaire's Village,
has Rohan confront his greatest foe:good manners. The story stars
Rohan and another editor of his as he accompanies her to a buy a home
in a remote village. Here we're shown a more caring side of Rohan as
he does fight to win back his editor's life after losing her due to
the village’s strict upholding of good manners. While you could
read his care as more selfish ,i.e if she dies he'll be in big
trouble,it comes of to me as a bit of genuine concern on Rohan's
part.
The
fourth and final of more story driven parts is Poaching
Reef
and brings back minor character Tonio Trussardi. It's funny to see
Rohan just going along with the plot even though he points
out how silly it is. The story is the two go
poaching for rare albacore so that Tonio can possibly cure his dying
fiance. Not much to it,the plan gets botched and then Rohan unbotches
it. The story does bring up a weird detail in that the place the men
go to poach belongs to Josuke's family. Josuke appears at the end
and doesn't seem to mind that the men poached from his family's
waters. The issue sort of goes with the “just roll” with it tone
of the story,so I don't mind too much.
The
last story is Rohan
goes to Gucci.
It ran as a pseudo-advertisement manga in the magazine Spur and is
fairly pointless. The stories before it gave us a look at Rohan as
a eccentric man who has a selfish streak but can be a good person.
Here he's just a generic jerk to a random desk clerk at Gucci,a
fashion company, and then spouts adverts. The mess is in full color
but that just makes it look unappealingly gaudy in a way the series
tends to avoid. The panels are disjointed,and one character just
disappears with no warning,taking Rohan's wallet with her.
Interestingly enough this story is the only one to feature a stand
besides Kishibe's. The rest of the stories attribute the weird events
to nature or demons. It doesn’t make them weaker by any means but I
find it odd I guess. Maybe it was for the better as the Stand
introduced here is just silly. A boring attempt to advertise for a
brand the author favors.
In
the end,four pretty good stories and one poor advertisement for a
brand I probably can't afford. The stories are enjoyable and feel
like solid Jojo stories despite the lack of Stands.
Till
Next Time:Stay Positive
Wednesday, March 5, 2014
Things No One Cares About:Princess Knight
Osamu Tezuka is a name in manga that I love yet hate. On one hand he is the godfather of manga,responsible for classics like Astroboy and Blackjack. On the other hand I have a really hard time spelling his name. Joking aside I really do enjoy the man's work and acknowledge their influence on manga as an art form. Determined to be known as the Japanese Walt Disney,he wrote a multitude of different series and stories that spoke to all demographics. He also wrote what can be considered one of the first shojo manga:Princess Knight.
Princess Knight ran in Shojo club from
1953-1956.It 's a classic tale of fantasy adventure with a heavy
undertone of romance that is prevalent in stories written for girls.
Taking the time to address gender politics,what it truly means to
love and that angels can sometimes be really stupid. So lets see if
this classic holds up to the test of time or have I just been using
ind words to soften the blow.
The story follows Sapphire as she
starts the fine tradition of Shojo heroines being menaced by ugly
people. Seriously the story starts out fairly happy with some light
antics then takes a turn right into horrid town as tragedy upon
tragedy is heaped on Sapphire. Just when something finally does go
right,there is another villain or event that just comes back to smack
her down. It'd be comical if it wasn't handled so well. The awful
things are always within in the realm of possibility and there is an
undercurrent of hope that kept me going.
Before I go on and discuss the plot in
more detail,we need to get a core concept out of the way. The idea is
that at birth God(who may or may not be Zeus,more on the later)
assigns every child a boy or girl heart that defines their gender.
This is where most of my real gripes are found in the book.
Disbarring the vastness of the gender spectrum and various gender
issues that arise from this idea. I can't really be pissed about that
as it was early the fifties when these concepts were not exactly at
the forefront of the public mind. It's just not a well explained
concept,Sapphire is born with both due to a trickster angel and goes
to either extreme of the spectrum when she loses one of them. Yet it
seems that everyone else's heart does not cause that affect in them
that way. King Plastic is an annoying brat who doesn't truly mature
till he swallows Sapphire's male heart. Maybe Sapphire's hearts are
special but this is never really established.
This could be a statement on the fact
that regardless of what gender we are born as,we all have traits of
what would be consider the gender norm for the opposite gender. The
book constantly criticizes the idea that only men can rule and women
should be in supporting roles exclusively. It's fairly progressive
for it's time and does help it avoid the embarrassment that plague
some older works. That being said,I believe I get what Tezuka is
trying to get at but the heart concept is poorly explained and leads
to some possibly unintentional sexist moments.
Princess Knight also has a weird
concept of religion. It tends to stick to a general outline of
Christian beliefs in that there is a God who watch over us and
Satan(who is fabulous by the way). However Venus the goddess of
beauty shows up and also controls life and death. She refers to God
as father,which would make him either Uranus' private parts,which is
unlikely as he is drawn like Sunday school God. More likely this
makes him Zeus which explains his pulling a major jerk move during a
pivotal fight scene. Either way she's more than perfect to serve as
an antagonist to Sapphire and her prince's love. Calling back to
Circe the with also from the same mythology. It's not really a mark
against it as the whole story never really establish it one way or
another, I just though it was worth mentioning.
The villains in the story are all
fairly one note and simplistic however it's that simplicity that
makes them enjoyable. They all mostly desire power(excluding Venus)
and will be as evil as humanly possible to reach that goal. It's
entertaining in the same way Dio form the Jojo series is. They are
all easy to hate and make Sapphire much more likable.
Not that Sapphire has to try that hard
to be likable,as she is a kind heart ed person who truly believes in
love and doing good. We could call that mary-sue and to some extent
it really is but her purity and goodness comes back to bite her in
the rear. Her own naivete and inability to explain herself cause many
of her problems.You think she sits back and lets her love interest
solve things?Hell no,she's out thwarting schemes and proving herself
capable and heroic. You want her to see her triumph over evil and
finally ascend to her rightful place in life.
Her love interest Franz is no less
likable but could stand to learn to pay attention as all it takes is
a wig to fool the poor guy. A noble man who truly does love Sapphire
once he wraps his head around the various conspiracies going on. Her
secondary love interest is a pirate named Blood who gets what is
honestly one of the weirdest adventures (I can't really do it
justice)in the plot all to himself. The rest of the supporting cast
is nothing special though Sapphire's nurse gets points for being
utterly entertaining. Tink,the angel who started this whole mess is
one of the more complex side characters. His trickster nature
developing into something outside of being a jerk and helping get
Sapphire out of many late story binds.
The plot itself is complex enough to be
interesting without getting overly dense. It can be broken down into
three intertwining plots all involving various factions needing
Sapphire dead. The antagonists of each plot tend to come and go as
the plot demands. The witch,Hell, leaves the main plot halfway
through to pursue her own slightly related plot. It sort of helps the
story feel slightly grander as there are these various plots going on
while Sapphire is pursuing her own agenda. I'll admit that the third
act feels slightly tacked on but includes enough awesome scenes that
this hardly becomes an issue.
The art work her is either love it or
hate it. It's very reminiscent of older Disney style shorts,with
exaggerated features and funny background events going on constantly.
Special note should go to the animals,as they are wholly awesome.
This series is the gold standard for horse drawing,there is a horse
early who is just plain great. I'd put his picture here just for
everyone to bask in his glory but the internet lacks his picture and
that's a damn shame.
Friday, February 21, 2014
Things No One Cares About: Futatabi
Every time Kentaro Miura shows up here I end up making fun of the man's work. To be honest I feel bad for doing it because I really love Berserk. It is to me a modern classic in the making and I refuse to believe he just got lucky. I know he didn't do the stories for Japan and King of Wolves but the art wasn't that stellar either. He had some success as an ammeter manga-ka and it's clear he knows what he's doing. You know what maybe he just sort of got dragged into the Buroson team-ups to build his reputation. He's defiantly not a bad writer so maybe if he has full control like he does for Berserk maybe things will turn out for the best. Enough speculating on the past,lets move on to Futatabi.
Futatabi was Miura's first public
release that wasn't a doujinshi. Released in 1985,it was a hit and
won him a best new authors award .This would be four years before the
first ill fated team-up with Buroson and Berserk Prototype .After
this he would end up in a rut with the falling out of his next manga Noa
but for now he had a great victory. So has this little one shot stood
the test of time or is it another work that makes Berserk look like
even more of a miracle. Well enough speculating...for real this time.
The plot is a rather simple animal,
though I 'm not sure if can be sterilized by alcohol . The twists
outside of one clever one are pretty easy to guess. It follows a auto
mechanic named Rick in a futuristic/totalitarian city and his chance
meeting with a mysterious girl named Venus. The plot heavily relies
on a series of twists that actually sets up a very interesting
premise(which I'm not spoiling). The problem is that once it sets up
said premise,it doesn't do much with it. Instead opting to go with a
weak theme of hope. So weak that it has to be explained in a short
paragraph that also reveals where the story takes place. There is
also a revelation near the end that answers question that no one
was asking and raises some new ones. The ending itself is lacking
with that ridiculous paragraph that just seems to scream “I ran out
of ink and I'm on a deadline.” It is a real gut punch as the story
had manged to draw me in and just having it end abruptly with that is
silly.
Rick and Venus are by no means bad
characters,their interactions do reveal more about the world in which
they live in. However,Rick is your stock good guy and Venus is the
mysterious girl. There are no real slants to their characters that
make them stand out from anyone else That being said,they still do
play off each other very well. The conversations they have between
themselves and with other characters really do build up this world
that I actually want to see more off but you know one shot.
The art is pretty great and actually
does help the above mentioned clever twist. It does seems to draw
from other sci-fi anime and manga without really anything to set it
apart. However it still looks very nice for an early Miura work and
shows that yes this man has a sense of perspective. Something he
seemed to forget in King of Wolves. It is also nice to see him draw
something besides barren wastelands so I actually have sights to see.
Weirdly enough reading this reminded me
of Sweet Rein of all things. Mind you,Not so much for the art or
anything but the squandered premise. Both had so much potential to be
something great but instead went in an okay albeit less intrenching
direction. This is a book worth checking out but like Sweet Rein
you'll probably forget about it in a weeks time.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)